'The Hunting Party': Will Josh Dallas Return to Manifest Season 5?

Fans of Netflix's "Manifest" are buzzing after a cryptic comment from stars Melissa Roxburgh and Josh Dallas about the possibility of Dallas returning to the show, despite his character's, Ben Stone’s, apparent fate. During a fan event discussing "The Hunting Party," the penultimate episode, Roxburgh hinted at a potential return, and Dallas added fuel to the fire with a knowing "Just think of the boots and the shoes..."

What Happened to Ben Stone? (Spoiler Alert!)

For those who haven't finished "Manifest," be warned: major spoilers ahead! Ben Stone, played by Josh Dallas, seemingly met his end in the final season. He sacrificed himself to save his daughter, Eden, and stop Angelina, the main antagonist. The emotional impact of his death was profound, leaving a significant void in the show and affecting all the remaining characters.

Decoding the Hint: What Does "Boots and Shoes" Mean?

So, what does Dallas's cryptic "boots and shoes" comment signify? This is where the speculation begins. Several theories are circulating among fans:

• Flashbacks: The most likely scenario is that Dallas could return in flashbacks. The show frequently uses flashbacks to explore the characters' pasts and shed light on their present situations. Seeing Ben in these flashbacks would provide emotional depth and closure.
• The Afterlife: Given the mystical nature of "Manifest" and its exploration of the afterlife through the Callings, Ben could appear in a more spiritual form, perhaps guiding Olive or Michaela.
• A Twist Resurrection (Unlikely): While less probable, the possibility of a "Manifest"-style resurrection can't be entirely ruled out. The show has surprised us before, and perhaps there’s a loophole or undiscovered element that could bring him back.

Why This News Matters

The possibility, even slight, of Josh Dallas reprising his role is huge for "Manifest" fans. Ben Stone was a central character, the emotional core of the Stone family, and a driving force behind solving the mystery of Flight 828. His presence resonated deeply with viewers, and his absence was keenly felt in the finale. A return, in any form, would offer solace and potentially resolve some lingering questions surrounding his character's arc.

Our Analysis

In our opinion, a full resurrection of Ben Stone would undermine the emotional weight of his sacrifice. The writers crafted a powerful scene that underscored the importance of family and selflessness. Cheapening that moment with a sudden, unexplained revival would be a disservice to the story.

However, flashbacks or appearances in the afterlife would be a welcome addition. These avenues would allow Dallas to return without compromising the integrity of Ben's sacrifice. They could provide closure, offer guidance to other characters, and ultimately enhance the overall narrative.

The "boots and shoes" comment likely alludes to behind-the-scenes work. Even if the role is limited, Dallas may have been present during filming, even if just for wardrobe or a brief cameo. This offers a glimmer of hope for fans.

Future Outlook

The future of Josh Dallas's involvement in "Manifest" remains uncertain. Netflix is keeping its cards close to its chest. However, the hints dropped by the cast suggest that we haven't seen the last of Ben Stone. We anticipate that we'll see Josh Dallas in some format in Season 5, it is just a question of in what capacity.

This could impact how fans view the ending. Did Ben really sacrifice himself, or are there more mysteries to come? It's going to change the viewing experience in either scenario and adds another layer of intrigue to the already convoluted story.

As we approach the release date of the final season, expect more teases and speculation. For now, fans can hold onto the hope that Ben Stone's story isn't completely over.